Benefits of Multiple Boilers
There are more reasons to do multiple boilers today than ever before. This creates a system that will save the most fuel and some protection against freeze ups in the case of boiler failure. If one boiler fails the second can still give off heat. The home may not be totally comfortable depending on outside air temperature, but will be warmer than no heat at all. The biggest reason to consider multiple boilers is our hot water demand has increased over the last decade. We now have large whirlpool 90 gallon tubs, hot tubs, multi-head shower stalls, full baths for each bedroom, clothes washers, dishwashers and 14+ gpm faucets. We are concerned about cutting heating costs but are not concerned about hot water costs. We install high efficiency boilers and furnaces but may not make the wisest choice for water heaters. The indirect water heater has become more popular over the last decade or two. Most indirect water heaters are well insulated and have a coil which boiler water goes through to heat the domestic water in the tank. There is another style where that is a tank in a tank, and the boiler water flows between the two tanks. Both styles will supply plenty of efficient hot water in a very well insulated tank. Since the tank is not connected to a chimney it does not cool down as rapidly. The chimney will pull lots of heat from anything connected to it plus a lot of room air so the chimney stays warm all the time. As the tank size increases the boiler output must increase. See chart. As the hot water demand increases and the heat loss decreases it creates a problem with matching a boiler to an indirect. The larger boiler will heat the domestic hot water well but will short cycle during the heating cycle. If the boiler short cycles, the efficiency will be reduced.
The idea of possibly using two boilers instead of one makes the most sense with large differences between heat loss and large hot water demands. One boiler will fire and heat the home with the assistance of, if needed the second boiler. This is done with controls which are plentiful today and included with the mod/con boilers. When there is a domestic hot water demand both boilers can fire up and heat the tank rapidly. The choice for using two boilers or one becomes a fuel saving choice not an up front cost choice. The multiple boiler installations will be more expensive than one larger boiler.
Things to look at when making this choice is what is the heat loss and domestic hot water demand. If the heat loss is considerably less than the domestic hot water demand or visa versa it would be a good choice providing you do not have a long recovery time, until hot water may be drawn again. Let me explain. Let's assume you have a large hot tub. Other than that there are no big demands. You only fill the large tub maybe 3 - 4 times a week. You have a long time to recover the indirect water heater unless while you are in the hot tub or immediately after someone wants a shower. Handle this one of three ways.
One - Install two indirect's. One for all the hot water demands except the hot tub and one for the hot tub. Two - Install a large boiler or two smaller boilers staged with a good staging control.
Two - Install one bigger tank and a large boiler or two smaller boilers fired as needed. Drawing 1
The decision to install two boilers is not uncommon today with heating loads larger than 150,000 BTU's. Install two modulating/condensing (mod/con) or cast iron boilers, and stage the firing. One boiler will fire and heat the home. If it cannot get the water temperature up to the required temperature the second boiler will fire up. The second boiler will fire up and shut down multiple times on a call for heat. When the second boiler is off your fuel savings is the greatest. This creates a larger fuel savings than just one larger mod/con or cast iron boiler.
Three - Install one indirect sized for the hot water demand but not the hot tub. Install One larger or two smaller boilers and a good staging control. Handle the large tub demand from a separate water heater. Below you will see some drawings of boilers with and without an indirect.
Here is a decision to install two boilers and an indirect water heater. This choice was made due to a large hot water demand and a smaller heat demand. One boiler will fire for heat and the second boiler will fire it needed. It will not fire for every heating cycle. When the indirect calls both boilers will fire. One may drop out and fire back up again before the call for tank recovery ends.
The decision here is to increase the domestic hot water storage for larger hot water demand. Multiple boilers were chosen due to the large domestic hot water demand and smaller heat load. The tanks are piped reverse return which balances the flow between the two tanks. The boilers will need to be staged and fire on and off as required. The boilers will all fire on a call for hot water and drop out as the temperature in the tank increases.
Here the decision was made to have two indirect hot water tanks. One for the hot water in the whole house and one for a large demand such as a whirlpool tub, hot tub or whatever the demand is. Again multiple boilers were chosen due to a large domestic demand and a smaller heat demand. This is the most efficient way to treat a large demand as the recovery time can be longer for the large demand. If the big whirlpool tub is used occasionally and not used again for 24 hours or so, we can use smaller boilers due to being able to take longer to heat the bigger tank. We can prioritize the smaller tank but no the bigger tank as it will have a longer time to recover before using again. This will also give us faster recovery on the smaller tank, if the demand is needed. The down side of this installation is the large demand will need to be piped directly from the tank to the large demand device.
Disclaimer: The information found on this
web site is for informational purposes only. Any and all preventive maintenance,
service, installations should be reviewed on a per job situation. Any work performed
on your heating system should be performed by qualified and experienced
personnel only. Comfort-Calc or it's personnel accepts no responsibility for
improper information, application, damage to property or bodily injury from
applied information found on this web site as it should be reviewed by a professional.